Free senior care guidance for Greater Cleveland families. No cost to you, ever.
Call (216) 483-7940
Cleveland Senior AdvisorLocal Advisors, Honest Answers

Her Living Will Is in the Hutch. In Ohio, That Will Not Stop the Paramedics.

An Ohio living will only switches on after two physicians agree a parent is terminal or permanently unconscious. Until then, only a signed State of Ohio DNR order form speaks to a paramedic, and Ohio rewrote those rules effective September 8, 2025.

Quick answer

An Ohio living will only switches on after two physicians agree a parent is terminal or permanently unconscious. Until then, only a signed State of Ohio DNR order form speaks to a paramedic, and Ohio rewrote those rules effective September 8, 2025.

Home›Guides›Her Living Will Is in the Hutch. In Ohio, That Will

By Cleveland Senior Advisor Care Team · November 15, 2026

Short answer

An Ohio living will only switches on after two physicians agree a parent is terminal or permanently unconscious. Until then, only a signed State of Ohio DNR order form speaks to a paramedic, and Ohio rewrote those rules effective September 8, 2025.

The living will is in the folder. The night it matters, it may not apply.

Most Cleveland families we talk to have done the paperwork. Mom signed a living will and a health care power of attorney years ago, probably at a bank or a parish seminar, and the originals sit in a folder in the dining room hutch. The daughter in Shaker Heights knows where it is. Everyone assumes the question is settled.

Then a parent collapses at home at two in the morning, somebody calls 911, and the paperwork in the hutch does not do what the family expected. Ohio paramedics arriving at a private residence will begin CPR unless they find a specific, state-approved piece of identification saying not to. A living will, by itself, usually is not that identification.

This is not a technicality or a loophole. The Ohio State Bar Association says it plainly in its public Law Facts pamphlet on do-not-resuscitate orders: “A living will may not protect you from receiving CPR or other medical interventions that may prolong life.” The reason is in the statute. Under ORC 2133.03, an Ohio living will becomes operative only after it has been communicated to the attending physician, the attending physician and one other examining physician agree the declarant is in a terminal condition or a permanently unconscious state, and the attending physician determines there is no reasonable possibility of regaining the capacity to make informed decisions.

None of that can happen on a living room floor. Two physicians are not standing in the hallway in Parma at 2 a.m. The document is real, it is legally sound, and in that moment it is doing nothing, because the conditions that switch it on have not been met and the medics have no way to establish that they have.

Ohio has two DNR orders, and only one of them changes anything today

The document that does work at home is the State of Ohio DNR order form, signed by an authorized health care provider. Ohio runs it through Ohio Administrative Code Chapter 3701-62, the state’s do-not-resuscitate protocol. The current version of those rules took effect September 8, 2025, so a form signed years ago is worth a look alongside a current one.

Families are rarely told that the single form carries two very different orders, and that choosing between them is the actual decision. The protocol appendix adopted at OAC 3701-62-05 defines both.

DNR Comfort Care is activated immediately, the moment the order is issued. From that point forward, the person receives the comfort measures the protocol allows and nothing on the prohibited list, whether or not anything has gone wrong yet. DNR Comfort Care – Arrest sits dormant. The person gets every intervention Ohio medicine has, intubation and a ventilator included, right up until the heart or breathing stops. The protocol activates only at that point, and the rule defines the trigger tightly: cardiac arrest is “absence of a palpable pulse,” and respiratory arrest is “absence of spontaneous respirations or presence of agonal breathing.”

In practice, Arrest is what most families actually mean when they say they want a DNR for a parent who is frail but not dying. They mean: treat her pneumonia, but do not restart her heart. Plain DNR Comfort Care is what a hospice family usually means. Signing the wrong box produces exactly the outcome the family was trying to avoid, and the protocol itself warns the responder to check which one applies before acting.

What the protocol permits, line by line

Ohio does not leave this to interpretation. The protocol appendix is a two-column list, and every emergency responder and facility in the state works from the same one. This is the whole of it:

Under the Ohio DNR protocol, responders WILLUnder the Ohio DNR protocol, responders WILL NOT
Conduct an initial assessmentPerform CPR
Perform basic medical careInsert an artificial airway adjunct
Clear the airway of obstruction or suctionAdminister resuscitation medications intended to restart the heart or breathing
Administer oxygen, CPAP or BiPAP if needed for comfort or to relieve distressDefibrillate, cardiovert or initiate pacing
Obtain IV access for hydration or pain medication to relieve discomfort, but not to prolong deathInitiate continuous cardiac monitoring
Contact other providers where possible, such as hospice, home health or the physician, APRN or PA 

Read the left column again. Oxygen is on it. Pain medication is on it. Suctioning an airway is on it. A family that has been told a DNR means their mother will be left on the floor untouched has been told something false.

What is absent from both columns is any limit on ordinary treatment. The protocol governs resuscitation at the moment of arrest, and nothing else. It does not decline antibiotics for a urinary tract infection, a hip repair after a fall on an icy Lakewood driveway, or a hospital admission for pneumonia.

Which paper, and which jewelry, actually counts

OAC 3701-62-04, also effective September 8, 2025, lists every form of DNR identification Ohio recognizes. There are seven: the State of Ohio DNR order form itself; a wallet card; a clear hospital-style bracelet with the state insert; a necklace bearing the state logo and the person’s name; a bracelet bearing the same; a copy of an operative, unrevoked living will declaration that authorizes withholding CPR; and a printed living will form distributed under ORC 2133.07 on which the declarant has stated it serves as DNR identification.

Note what the two living will routes have in common. The rule makes a person eligible through a living will only if the declaration authorizes withholding CPR, has not been revoked, and is operative. That last word carries the two-physician finding back into the equation, which is why the form and the jewelry are the practical answer for someone living at home with years, not weeks, ahead.

The jewelry is not decorative and not optional-but-nice. For a DNR Comfort Care – Arrest patient, the necklace or bracelet must also carry the word “arrest.” Without it, a responder reading a plain DNR necklace has no way to know the family wanted full treatment up until the heart stopped. Manufacturers will not ship an item without a copy of the signed order form, and no pharmacy or facility will issue the hospital-style bracelet without one either.

One rule surprises people who like to annotate things. The form “will not be altered or modified in any way,” and that includes writing care instructions on it. Anything written on the form beyond its required elements is not portable and carries none of the chapter’s legal protections. Wishes about feeding tubes, hospitalization or dialysis belong in the living will and the health care power of attorney, not in the margin of the DNR form.

Who can sign it, and what a family member cannot do at the door

A DNR order has to come from an authorized health care provider. Under ORC 2133.211, effective April 6, 2017, that is an attending physician, an APRN acting under a standard care arrangement with a collaborating physician, or a physician assistant acting under a supervision agreement. In Greater Cleveland, where a great many older adults see a nurse practitioner for primary care at a Cleveland Clinic or University Hospitals office, that matters: the person who knows your mother best can very often sign the form.

Families cannot write one themselves, and they also cannot undo one in the moment. The patient may revoke a DNR order orally or in writing, by asking for resuscitation, by destroying the identification, or through the attending physician. An adult child demanding CPR in the driveway is not a revocation. Pro Seniors, the nonprofit that runs Ohio’s legal helpline for people 60 and older, puts it bluntly in its guide to the DNR law: family demands for resuscitation do not change what emergency personnel may do.

That is the argument to have now, in a kitchen in Mayfield Heights, with everybody awake. If one sibling thinks a signed Arrest order is premature, the time to say so is before the form exists, not while a medic is reading a wallet card.

On identity, the protocol is practical. Responders are not required to go hunting for identification, but once they find it they make reasonable efforts to confirm it belongs to the person in front of them, by photo ID or by asking the patient, the family or a caregiver. For a resident of a facility whose chart carries the order, that verification step is not needed.

The move from hospital to rehab to assisted living is where this falls apart

A DNR order written on a Cleveland Clinic or MetroHealth floor can be documented in the medical record, and that documentation is valid only inside the facility holding the record. The moment your parent is discharged to a rehab unit or an assisted living community, something has to travel with her.

OAC 3701-62-09, new with the September 8, 2025 rules, sets out what the sending facility owes you. Before or at the time of transfer it must tell the receiving facility that the DNR order or identification exists, and tell whoever is transporting her, whether that is an EMS crew or a private ambulance. If the order was given orally, it has to be written onto the State of Ohio form before she moves. And the original or a copy of the signed form, or approved identification, has to go with her.

That is the rule. The practical problem is that these transfers happen on a Friday afternoon, through three different staff members who have never met each other. Ask the discharge planner directly whether the DNR form is in the transfer packet, and ask to see it. We have no published figure for how often it goes missing in Northeast Ohio, because nobody collects that number, which is exactly why a family member checking the packet is worth more than an assumption.

There is a further wrinkle on the receiving end. Physicians, APRNs, PAs and facilities are not compelled to follow the DNR protocol, and a facility may require an order to be reissued before it will act on one. What a facility may not do is block or delay a transfer to a provider that will honor it. Ohio also requires a residential care facility to disclose its advance directive and DNR policies, which is one of the items we flag in our walkthrough of what an Ohio assisted living contract has to tell you. Read that section before move-in, not after.

Ohio never adopted MOLST, so this one form carries all the weight

In a number of states, a frail older adult carries a single portable medical order covering resuscitation, hospitalization, feeding and antibiotics, known as MOLST or POLST. Ohio does not have one. LeadingAge Ohio, which has pushed the legislature on this for years, states that Ohio “has yet to adopt MOLST as a standard, statewide order set.” A Senate bill cleared the Ohio Senate in 2016 and stalled in the House.

So the Ohio toolkit is three separate documents doing three separate jobs. The health care power of attorney names who decides when your parent cannot, and that is the document that keeps a family out of Cuyahoga County Probate Court asking for guardianship. The living will states what she wants if she is terminal or permanently unconscious. The DNR order, and only the DNR order, speaks to a paramedic in her hallway tonight.

Families who have one of the three and assume they have all three are the ones who get surprised. Hospice enrollment does not automatically produce a DNR order either, and neither does a dementia diagnosis, however advanced.

What to do before the next appointment

Find the folder and read what is actually in it. If the only documents are a living will and a health care power of attorney, there is no DNR order, whatever the family believes. If there is a DNR form, check which box is marked, Comfort Care or Comfort Care – Arrest, and check whether that still matches what your parent wants.

Then put it on the agenda for the next visit with her physician, APRN or PA, as an item of its own rather than a question at the door on the way out. Ask for the form, ask for the wallet card at the same time, and ask whether the office stocks the hospital-style bracelet or whether you order the necklace yourself. Keep the signed original somewhere a medic will find it in ninety seconds, which in most houses means the front of the refrigerator rather than a hutch drawer, and make sure every adult child and every in-home caregiver knows it exists and what it says.

If the legal side needs a second opinion, Pro Seniors runs a free legal helpline for Ohio residents age 60 and over at 1-800-488-6070, Monday through Friday. For a problem with how a licensed facility is handling an advance directive, the long-term care ombudsman for Cuyahoga, Geauga, Lake, Lorain and Medina counties is Region 10A, at 1-800-365-3112; Western Reserve Area Agency on Aging covers the same five counties for options counseling at 1-800-626-7277. If your parent lives in Summit or Portage County, those are a different agency’s territory, which we cover in our piece on the aging agency split.

Talk to a Cleveland advisor about your situation →

Questions Cleveland families ask

Does a living will stop paramedics from performing CPR in Ohio?

Usually not. An Ohio living will becomes operative only after the attending physician and a second physician agree the person is terminal or permanently unconscious, a determination nobody can make in a living room. Without approved DNR identification, Ohio paramedics will begin CPR.

What is the difference between DNR Comfort Care and DNR Comfort Care - Arrest?

DNR Comfort Care activates immediately when the order is issued, so comfort measures replace resuscitative ones right away. DNR Comfort Care - Arrest activates only when the heart or breathing stops, meaning full treatment, including intubation, continues until that moment.

Can a nurse practitioner sign an Ohio DNR order?

Yes. Under ORC 2133.211, an APRN acting under a standard care arrangement with a collaborating physician, or a physician assistant under a supervision agreement, may issue a DNR order, as may the attending physician. Families cannot write one themselves.

Does an Ohio DNR order follow a parent from the hospital to a nursing home?

Only if someone carries it. OAC 3701-62-09 requires the sending facility to notify the receiving facility and the transport crew, convert any oral order onto the state form before transfer, and send the signed form or approved identification with the patient.

Does a DNR mean the paramedics will not treat her at all?

No. Ohio's protocol expressly permits assessment, basic medical care, airway clearing, oxygen, CPAP or BiPAP for comfort, and IV access for hydration or pain relief. The order governs resuscitation at the moment of arrest, not ordinary treatment of illness or injury.

Can a family member cancel a DNR order when the ambulance arrives?

No. The patient may revoke it, including by asking for resuscitation or destroying the identification, but a relative's demand at the scene is not a revocation. Disagreements belong in the conversation before the form is signed, not at the door.

Not sure where to start?

Answer five questions and a local advisor will come back with senior care options in Greater Cleveland that actually fit your situation and budget. It is free, and there is no obligation.

Find care options
Find Facilities Near You